Skip to content

Writing

Undoing Language: Early Performance Works by Brian O’ Doherty

512 West 19th Street

October 8, 2021, 7pm EDT

This program brings together early performance works by artist, art critic, poet, filmmaker, and novelist Brian O’Doherty. At age 93, this program recognizes O’Doherty’s role as an artist who created a substantial body of performance works engaging with the performativity of language and how it interacts with the performance of the “self”, and who led the first national funding for performance and media art at the National Endowment for the Arts in 1970s, making an indelible mark on the New York performance art scene.

The works being presented at The Kitchen stem from the period in which O’ Doherty developed a series of ten “Structural Plays” (1967–70) that “perform language” in ways that expose its instability, forming a performative precursor of post-structuralism. (Notably O’ Doherty was also the first person to publish Roland Barthes’ “Death of the Author” as guest-editor of Aspen 5&6 in 1967.) The event at The Kitchen will include live performances of two of these works, followed by a newly commissioned vocal work by Holland Andrews, responding to this oeuvre.

The evening will mark the first ever performance of Vowel Chorus for Five Voices (1968), the most elaborate of several “voice-works” made by O’ Doherty between 1967 and 1970. In this work, each of five performers are designated one vowel sound, as well as different times in which to sustain his or her vowel, and a choice of pitch (high, low, and middle registers). This work was influenced by O’ Doherty’s friendship with Morton Feldman, with whom he shared an ongoing interest in seriality. Perhaps because of the necessity of five trained voices, the work was never previously realized as a performance, being exhibited to date as a score/drawing. More than fifty years after its conception, it will be performed live by Ekmeles, a New York-based avant-garde music ensemble.

“Structural Play: Vowel Grid” (1970) will also be performed live; this is a work for two performers, who utter vowel sounds while traversing a grid-like floor drawing. This grid is a visual translation of the vowels; a kind of “phonic drawing” that spatializes language, made up of the linear alphabet of Ogham. Seeking to translate language into a serial notation, O’ Doherty turned to this ancient Celtic notation from his native country as “a non-expressive compositional tool” (Brenda Moore-McCann). The horizontal and diagonal lines that form the basis of the colored grid are “abstract” visual translations of the vowels, rotated and transposed to make a drawing that can be performed as an open-ended score.

O’ Doherty’s engagement with Ogham manifests his interest in serialism as an open and polyvalent thought-process that poses an alternative to classical thought. His emphasis on the physicality of language reflects an affinity with (Irish) oral culture, as oral literature inhabits the body rather than the page. Unlike peer Conceptualists and post-Minimalists in New York, O’ Doherty explored the relationship between language and identity, with the “Structural Plays” “rotating” sentences (and thus testing the stability of) being one person, here, now. They manifest a decolonial gesture in their juxtaposition of the ancient language of a colonized country with the language of Conceptual art.

The guttural vowel sounds in O’ Doherty’s linguistic performances will form the departure point for a newly commissioned work by Holland Andrews, an extended technique vocalist, composer, and performer who use combined vocal layering to create dissonant soundscapes. Their work will extend the embodied to language of O’ Doherty’s vowel performances, unpacking their layers in a soundscape.

O’ Doherty’s interest in the embodiment and performativity of language formed part of a wider interest in the performativity of the self. Alongside his practice under his given name, O’Doherty further explored the “self” as a fluid entity by working under four additional identities constructed for specific conceptual functions: Mary Josephson, a feminist academic; Sigmund Bode, a linguistic theorist; poet William Maginn, and Patrick Ireland, an artistic identity created in a 1972 performance in protest of the loss of civil rights in Northern Ireland during Bloody Sunday.

This program is guest-curated by Lucy Cotter.

Biographies:

Brian O’Doherty is an artist, art critic, novelist, filmmaker, and poet, who has worked under several identities. Born in Ireland in 1928 and trained as a doctor, he began his art career in the 1960s in New York. As an artist he works with drawing, installation and performance, exhibiting in museums and galleries worldwide. He is the author of two books and three novels, one of which was Man-Booker prize nominated. He was art critic for the New York Times in the 1960s and editor of Art in America in the ‘70s and is best known for his paradigm-shifting* Inside the White Cube* essays (1976). Recent publications and monographs include: the artist’s novel A Crossdresser’s Secret, Sternberg Press, 2014; the critical anthology Brian O’Doherty/Patrick Ireland: Word, Image and Institutional Critique edited by Christa-Maria Lerm Hayes, 2017; Brian O’ Doherty: Collected Essays published by University of California Press, 2018; and A Mental Masquerade, edited by Thomas Fischer and Astrid Mania, Spector Books, 2019.

Lucy Cotter is an Irish curator and writer whose practice embraces the intersections of art, politics, and the unknown. She is based in Portland, OR, where she is Curator in Residence 2021 at Oregon Center for Contemporary Art. Previous projects include being curator of the Dutch Pavilion, 57th Venice Biennale (2017) with Cinema Olanda: Wendelien van Oldenborgh. She is author-editor of Reclaiming Artistic Research (2019) and a contributor to journals such as Flash Art,* Frieze*, and Mousse Magazine. Cotter holds a PhD in Cultural Analysis from the University of Amsterdam and lectures in Critical Theory at Portland State University. She is currently working on an experimental play entitled The Entangled Museum, a solo exhibition with Katarina Zdjelar (2021), and an exhibition exploring the archives of Maya Lin’s Confluence project (2022).

Ekmeles is a vocal ensemble dedicated to the performance of new and rarely heard works, and gems of the historical avant-garde. Praised as a "brilliant young ensemble... defining a fresh and virtuosic American sound" by The New Yorker, they have given US premieres of works by Beat Furrer, Luigi Nono, and Salvatore Sciarrino. In 2019–2020 they performed with the MET Museum's first commissioned sound installation, Oliver Beer's Vessel Orchestra, and released their debut album "A howl, that was also a prayer" on New Focus Recordings, with works by Taylor Brook, Erin Gee, and Christopher Trapani.

Holland Andrews is a vocalist, composer, and performance artist whose work focuses on the abstraction of operatic and extended-technique voice to build soundscapes encompassing both catharsis and dissonance. Frequently highlighting themes surrounding vulnerability and healing, Andrews arranges music for voice, clarinet, and electronics. Andrews also develops and performs soundscapes for dance, theater, and film, and their work is toured internationally with artists such as Bill T. Jones, Dorothee Munyaneza, Will Rawls, and poet Demian Dinéyazhi. Notable musical collaborations include William Brittelle, Son Lux, Christina Vantzou, Peter Broderick, and Methods Body.

Undoing Language: Early Performance Works by Brian O’Doherty is made possible with endowment support from Mary Flagler Cary Charitable Trust; annual grants from The Amphion Foundation, Inc., The Aaron Copland Fund for Music, Howard Gilman Foundation, and The Fan Fox and Leslie R. Samuels Foundation; and in part by public funds from New York City Department of Cultural Affairs in partnership with the City Council and New York State Council on the Arts with the support of Governor Kathy Hochul and the New York State Legislature.

Writing

Lucy Cotter is a prolific writer; publishing art criticism, cultural criticism, art history, art theory, ficto-theory, poetry, exhibition, performance, cross-disciplinary texts, and catalogue essays. She seeks to create a more generative relationship between art making and writing.

She is the author of Reclaiming Artistic Research (Hatje Cantz, 2019, expanded 2nd ed. 2024), a book foregrounding the singular nature of artistic thinking in dialogue with acclaimed artists worldwide. She is a regular contributor to books on contemporary art by academic presses, and has published in catalogues and monographs on Haegue Yang, Rabih Mroué, Katarina Zdjelar, Brian Maguire, Manuela Infante, and Brian O’ Doherty, among other artists.

She is the editor of several exhibition catalogues, including Cinema Olanda: Wendelien Van Oldenborgh for the 57th Venice Biennale, and has guest-edited a number of art journals, including Third Text. Her work has appeared in Flash Art, Mousse, Artforum, Hyperallergic, Oregon Artswatch, CARA, Field Day, The Brooklyn Rail, Typishly, Cirque, and Frieze, among other journals.

Books

  • Reclaiming Artistic Research: Expanded Second Edition

    Berlin: Hatje Cantz

    Expanding the original book with additional artist dialogues and a new essay, this edition explores the changing stakes of artistic research in a world reckoning with social justice, climate change, and the rise of artificial intelligence through a series of 24 in-depth dialogues with artists worldwide.

    2024
  • Reclaiming Artistic Research

    Berlin: Hatje Cantz

    In twenty conversations with leading artists worldwide, Lucy Cotter maps out an epistemology of artistic creation. She manifests a type of research that is dynamically engaged with other fields, but thinks beyond concepts into bodily and material knowledge that exceeds language, revolutionizing our perception of art from the ground up.

    2019

Books in Progress

Books Chapters & Essays

  • unraveling: practice-led curating

    Companion to Curatorial Futures

    Bridget Crone, Bassam el Baroni, Matthew Poole, eds.

    Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press

    forthcoming 2025
    2025
  • Global Engagement and Modalities of Looking in the Work of Brian Maguire, Richard Mosse, and Yuri Pattison

    Routledge Companion to Irish Art

    Fionna Barber and Fintan Cullen, eds.

    London: Routledge

    forthcoming 2025
    2025
  • Haegue Yang: Day and Night

    Haegue Yang: The Great Forgetfulness

    Fergal Gaynor, ed.

    Cork: National Sculpture Factory

    forthcoming 2024
    2024
  • Delegitimizing the Continuum of Violence

    Brian Maguire: The Grand Illusion

    Dublin: The Hugh Lane National Gallery

    2024
  • Fact as Fiction: A Dialogue with Rabih Mroué

    Rabih Mroué: Interviews

    Nadim. Samman, ed.

    Berlin: Hatje Cantz

    2023
  • Theatre as Thinking, Art as Nonknowledge

    Manuela Infante: Estado Vegetal: Performance and Plant-Thinking

    Giovanni Aloi, ed.

    Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press

    2023
  • The Warp and Weft of History

    Kristina Benjocki: The Warp and Weft of History

    Amsterdam: Looiersgracht 60

    2023
  • Braiding: Transgenerational Artistic Comradeship

    Katarina Zdjelar (monograph)

    Middlesborough: Institute of Modern Art & Teeside University

    2022
  • (tropisms) away from and towards the thing, it, she

    Natasha Pike (artist's book)

    Dublin: Arts Council

    2022
  • Beyond the Walls of National Identity: The Triangulation of Art Criticism, Curatorial Discourse, and Artistic Practice

    Irish Art 1920–2020: Perspectives on Change

    Yvonne Scott and Christine Kennedy, eds.

    Dublin: Royal Hibernian Academy

    2022
  • After a While, Reflectively: Performing an Ecology of Composition Practice (On Alison Isadora)

    Fieldings: Propositions for 3rd Cycle Education in the Performing Arts

    Julien Bruneau, Nienke Scholts, Konstantina Georgelou, and Sher Doruff, eds.

    Amsterdam: DAS, University of the Arts

    2021
  • The Body as a Crease of Knowledge (On Mike O' Connor)

    Fieldings: Propositions for 3rd Cycle Education in the Performing Arts

    Julien Bruneau, Nienke Scholts, Konstantina Georgelou, and Sher Doruff, eds.

    Amsterdam: DAS, University of the Arts

    2021
  • Preparing for Liquefaction (On Siegmar Zacharias)

    Fieldings: Propositions for 3rd Cycle Education in the Performing Arts, eds. Julian Brumeau, Nienke Scholts et al. Amsterdam: DAS Publishing/Amsterdam University of the Arts

    2021
  • The Accidental Symbol: Performance as a Conduit (On Jennifer Lacey)

    Fieldings: Propositions for 3rd Cycle Education in the Performing Arts

    Julien Bruneau, Nienke Scholts, Konstantina Georgelou, and Sher Doruff, eds.

    Amsterdam: DAS, University of the Arts

    2021
  • Between and Beyond the Dramaturgical (On Nienke Scholts)

    Fieldings: Propositions for 3rd Cycle Education in the Performing Arts

    Julien Bruneau, Nienke Scholts, Konstantina Georgelou, and Sher Doruff, eds.

    Amsterdam: DAS, University of the Arts

    2021
  • Walking the Wrinkled Plane (On Gustavo Ciríaco)

    Fieldings: Propositions for 3rd Cycle Education in the Performing Arts

    Julien Bruneau, Nienke Scholts, Konstantina Georgelou, and Sher Doruff, eds.

    Amsterdam: DAS, University of the Arts

    2021
  • The Space Beyond Boundaries (On Rosie Heinrich)

    Fieldings: Propositions for 3rd Cycle Education in the Performing Arts

    Julien Bruneau, Nienke Scholts, Konstantina Georgelou, and Sher Doruff, eds.

    Amsterdam: DAS, University of the Arts

    2021
  • Art Stars and Plasters on the Wounds: Why Have There Been No Great Irish Artists?

    Sources in Irish Art 2: A Reader

    Fintan Cullen and Róisín Kennedy, eds.

    Cork: Cork University Press

    2021
  • Unknowing Culture

    Persistent Traces of Things to Come

    Marjoca de Greef and Anastasija Pandilovska, eds.

    Amsterdam: Sun and Stars

    2020
  • Mercurial States: A Curatorial Reflection

    Art and Education/Classroom

    2019
  • Towards an autonomy of self, towards a community of self

    Katarina Zdjelar: Vladimir

    Lucerne: Centre of Contemporary Art

    2019
  • Cinema Olanda: Toward a Platform, Realized and Anticipated

    Blessing and Transgressing: A Live Institute

    Defne Ayas, ed.

    London: Cornerhouse

    2018
  • Cinema Olanda: Projecting the Netherlands

    Cinema Olanda: Wendelien van Oldenborgh, ed. Lucy Cotter, Berlin: Hatje Cantz, p. 11–21

    2017
  • Between the White Cube and the White Box: Aspen 5+6

    Brian O Doherty/Patrick Ireland: Word, Image and Institutional Critique, ed. Christa Maria Lerm Hayes. Amsterdam: Valiz

    2017
  • Between the White Cube and the White Box: Brian O’Doherty’s Aspen 5+6, An Early Exposition

    The Exposition of Artistic Research: Publishing Art in Academia

    Michael Schwab and Henk Borgdorff, eds.

    Leiden: Leiden University Press.

    2014
  • Close Listening: Katarina Zdjelar’s My lifetime (Malaika)

    Katarina Zdjelar: Of More Than One Voice

    Vitoria-Gasteiz: Artium Basque Museum-Centre of Contemporary Art

    2013
  • 180 Degrees: The University after Artistic Research

    Art Education: A Glossary

    Tom Vandeputte, ed.

    Amsterdam: Sandberg Institute

    2013
  • Libia Olafur: The Future of Hospitality

    Under Deconstruction: Icelandic Pavilion, 54th Venice Biennale

    Ellen Blumenstein, ed.

    Berlin: Sternberg Press

    2011

The above contributions are selected from 2011–2024. A complete list from 2005–2024 is available on request.

Art Journals

  • TBA Review: FORCE! an opera in three acts

    Performance review, Oregon Arts Watch

    11 September 2024
    2024
  • Empathy and Eros: Ralph Pugay’s The Longest Journey

    Exhibition review, Oregon Arts Watch.

    11 December 2023
    2023
  • The Ingenious Multiplicity of Brian O’Doherty

    Tribute article, memorial publication,

    Brenda Moore-McCann, ed. The Brooklyn Rail.

    May 2023
    2023
  • The Weft of History: Kristina Benjocki at IKOB, Eupen

    Exhibition review, Metropolis M

    1 June 2022
    2022
  • Brian O’ Doherty, Paradigm-Shifting Artist Dies at 94

    Tribute article, Hyperallergic.

    9 November 2022
    2022
  • Disintegrating Language: Will Rawls’s “Amphigory”

    Exhibition Review, Oregon Arts Watch.

    23 November 2022
    2022
  • The Promise of “Opacity”: Takahiro Yamamoto’s Opacity of Performance at Portland Art Museum

    Performance review, Oregon Arts Watch

    24 June 2022
    2022
  • The Art of Zoom

    Essay: “The Art of Zoom”, republished, In the Pause of an Echo, There May Be A Shadow, online symposium publication.

    2020
  • The Art of Zoom

    Essay, RUUKU Journal for Artistic Research, Vol. 14

    6 August 2020
    2020
  • Wendelien van Oldenborgh at CA2M, Madrid

    Exhibition Preview, Artforum, Summer edition (print and digital).

    2019
  • The Exhibition after Time and Space: On Mario Garcia Torres’s Survey ‘Illusion brought Me Here’

    Essay, Mousse Magazine

    Spring 2019
    2019
  • Mia Habib, ALL – a physical poem of protest

    Performance review, Flash Art

    27 September 2019
    2019
  • Design as Relationality, Aesthetics as Agency (On dach&zephir)

    Essay, Sophie Krier, ed. Issue 4, Field Essays.

    2019
  • Plants as Other: Manuela Infante’s Estado Vegetal at Portland Institute of Contemporary Art

    Performance Review, Mousse Magazine

    17 May 2019
    2019
  • Beyond the White Cube: Sixty Years of Brian O’ Doherty’s Letters

    Book review, Frieze.

    25 February 2019
    2019
  • Rob Halverson, Enthusiastic-Remotest-Tree

    Exhibition review, Flash Art

    5 June 2019
    2019
  • An Intimate Dance of Objects: Gordon Hall

    Exhibition review, Mousse Magazine

    11 June 2019
    2019
  • Black Urban Choreography: NIC Kay’s Pushit!

    Performance Review, Mousse Magazine.

    26 October 2018
    2018
  • Research as Play: A Dialogue with Ryan Gander

    MaHKUscript Journal for Fine Art Research, Vol (3), Issue 1

    2018
  • Becoming the Archive: A Dialogue with Euridice Kala

    MaHKUscript Journal for Fine Art Research, Vol (3), Issue 1.

    2018
  • Knowledge as Production: A Dialogue with Liam Gillick

    MaHKUscript Journal for Fine Art Research, Vol (3), Issue 1

    2018
  • Beyond Language: A Dialogue with Falke Pisano

    MaHKUscript Journal for Fine Art Research, Vol (3), Issue 1.

    2018
  • Writing as Experiment: A Dialogue with Sher Doruff

    MaHKUscript Journal for Fine Art Research, Vol (3), Issue 1, 2018

    2018
  • Reclaiming Artistic Research… First Thoughts

    Introductory essay

    2018
  • Sound as Knowledge: A Dialogue with Samson Young

    MaHKUscript Journal for Fine Art Research, Vol (3), Issue 1

    2018

The above contributions are selected from 2017–2024 only. A list of earlier journal publications from 2003–2018 is available on request.

The keys of a computer are not entirely different than those of a piano. Fingers moving across a plane, producing sounds that are spoken or read. Tracing how material and embodied sensibilities can undermine the imposition of language; how words can act as placeholders for emerging subject positions and worldmaking. Embraced as a medium, writing aligns itself with the internal logic of art making.